The 21 Grams Doctor Weighed Dogs Too

The 21 Grams Doctor Weighed Dogs Too

Nov 06, 2026
64

The doctor who told the world the human soul weighs about 21 grams also weighed fifteen dogs, found no loss at all, and on May 10, 1907, the Evening News ran the headline "Doctors Say Dogs Have No Soul."

His name was Duncan MacDougall, a physician in Haverhill, Massachusetts. In April 1907, he published "Hypothesis Concerning Soul Substance Together with Experimental Evidence of The Existence of Such Substance" in American Medicine. He built a beam balance big enough to hold a patient's bed and put six dying patients on it, one at a time, to watch the beam at the moment each of them died.

His first patient was a man dying of tuberculosis. When the man died, MacDougall wrote, "the beam end dropped with an audible stroke." Then: "The loss was ascertained to be three-fourths of an ounce." That's about 21 grams, and that's where the number comes from.

So where did the other five patients land?

Only four of the six gave him results he trusted. Two lost about half an ounce, one lost three-eighths, and the first man lost three-fourths. He threw out one result because the scales weren't adjusted finely enough, and another because the patient died while he was still setting up. So "21 grams" is one man, in one bed, in 1907. MacDougall himself wrote that "a large number of experiments would require to be made before the matter can be proved."

The same paper ran that spring in the Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, and in that version his human subjects, he wrote, "all gave their consent to the experiment weeks before the day of death." (Nobody asked the dogs.)

So, what happened to the dogs?

"The same experiments were carried out on fifteen dogs," he wrote, and "the results were uniformly negative, no loss of weight at death." The historian Carlos Alvarado points out that the dogs weren't sick, so they were most likely put to death for the experiment. And in the same paper, MacDougall wrote that "the tests on dogs were vitiated by the use of two drugs." Vitiated means spoiled. So he drugged fifteen healthy dogs, wrote that the drugs spoiled the test, and the newspapers still got "Doctors Say Dogs Have No Soul" out of it. What the hell, Duncan.

A colleague, Augustus P. Clarke, argued with him in the pages of American Medicine that same year and had a simpler explanation. When a person dies, the lungs stop cooling the blood, the body heats up, and the skin sweats. Dogs don't have sweat glands, Clarke pointed out, so a dog wouldn't lose weight that way.

Did MacDougall think the soul was made of ether?

He argued about it in letters with the psychical researcher Richard Hodgson, which started in 1901 and were published in 1907. The ether was the invisible substance physicists of the day believed filled all of space. Hodgson suggested consciousness might have a body made "not of what is known as gross ponderable matter, but of the ether," and the ether couldn't be weighed. MacDougall held out for something material, and then gave this away: "it may be that there is a middle substance which is the soul substance, and which resembles the ether in being non-gravitative and therefore not weighable." So the man who put the soul on a scale admitted it might be something a scale can't weigh. (Duncan. Buddy.)

Has anyone weighed an animal at death with a modern scale?

In 2001, Lewis Hollander published a study in the Journal of Scientific Exploration that he called the first to use an electronic scale, since everyone before him had used beam balances. He put twelve animals that were already going to be put down on an electronic scale: one ram, seven ewes, three lambs, and a goat. He reported that seven of the adult sheep showed "an unexplained weight gain transient of 18 to 780 grams for 1 to 6 seconds" at the moment of death, and the lambs and the goat didn't. A gain, not a loss. In 2009, Masayoshi Ishida argued in the same journal that the 780 gram pulse "includes an overshoot reaction of the system," meaning the weighing setup itself bounced, but he also wrote that "the cause of the force event remains to be explained."

As for a repeat of the sheep test, I can't find one, and I looked hard. I went through the journal's own index of every article it published from Hollander's paper through 2019, and the only weight-at-death papers in it are Hollander's and two by Ishida, both worked out on paper with no animals on a scale. The Psi Encyclopedia's 2026 roundup of soul-weighing experiments lists nothing after Hollander except Ishida's simulations and a proposal by Gerard Nahum that he hasn't had the money to test in a lab. Ishida himself wrote that "perhaps Hollander's type of experiments using animals will add no new value to this field of research." (Thanks, Masayoshi. Very encouraging.) So as far as I can tell, Hollander's twelve animals are still the only electronic-scale test of animals at death on record.

What should you do with the 21 grams story?

The next time someone tells you the soul weighs 21 grams, tell them it's one man with tuberculosis, out of four results that didn't match, and that the one modern test found a gain.

Read MacDougall's paper yourself. It's short, and you can see how carefully he hedged it.

What do you make of Hollander's sheep, a gain at death in the grown ones and nothing in the lambs? Tell me your theory in the comments.

Further Reading


Alvarado, C. S. (2009). On Duncan MacDougall's Experiment on the Loss of Weight at Death. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 23, No. 3, pp. 343-347, Letters to the Editor [online] Available here: https://journalofscientificexploration.org/index.php/jse/article/view/91

Hollander, L. E., Jr. (2001). Unexplained Weight Gain Transients at the Moment of Death. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 15, No. 4, pp. 495-500.

Ishida, M. (2009). A New Experimental Approach to Weight Change Experiments at the Moment of Death with a Review of Lewis E. Hollander's Experiments on Sheep. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 5-28 [online] Available here: https://journalofscientificexploration.org/index.php/jse/article/download/105/43

Ishida, M. (2010). Rebuttal to Claimed Refutations of Duncan MacDougall's Experiment on Human Weight Change at the Moment of Death. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 5-39 [online] Available here: https://journalofscientificexploration.org/index.php/jse/article/view/67/116

Journal of Scientific Exploration (2019). Index of Previous Articles in the Journal of Scientific Exploration. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 33, No. 3.

MacDougall, D. (1907). Hypothesis Concerning Soul Substance Together with Experimental Evidence of The Existence of Such Substance. American Medicine, April 1907, reprinted at New Dualism Archive [online] Available here: https://newdualism.org/papers/D.MacDougall/soul-substance.htm

Schwarcz, J. (2019). The Real Story Behind "21 Grams." McGill Office for Science and Society [online] Available here: https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/did-you-know-general-science/story-behind-21-grams

Wehrstein, K. M. (2026). Soul Weighing Experiments. Psi Encyclopedia, Society for Psychical Research [online] Available here: https://psi-encyclopedia.spr.ac.uk/articles/soul-weighing-experiments/

Wikipedia (2026). 21 Grams Experiment. Wikipedia [online] Available here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_grams_experiment

UPCOMING WORKSHOPS:

Shift Your Timeline - Live on Zoom

Dates:
Sunday, November 29, 10AM to 7PM Eastern
Sunday, December 20, 10AM to 7PM Eastern

In this one-day live workshop, the audio guides your body into deep stillness while your mind stays fully awake and alert, opening you into a state of expanded consciousness. Then, we move into a state outside of time. While you’re in that state, you focus on embodying the life you want instead of the one you’re currently headed toward. The idea is that choosing it clearly, in that state, makes it more likely to happen.

Starfire Signals - Live on Zoom

Dates:
Monday, November 30, 8 PM to 10 PM Eastern
Tuesday, December 8, 10 AM to Noon Eastern
Monday, December 28, 8 PM to 10 PM Eastern

In this bimonthly live class, the audio settles your body into deep rest while keeping your mind fully alert, opening the door to expanded consciousness. In that relaxed state, you practice noticing what your intuition is telling you, and writing it down before you second-guess it. Over time, that makes it easier to trust what you’re sensing and helps you to tap into your own guidance on command.

Starfire Spark - Live on Zoom

Dates:
Thursday, November 19, 8:30 PM to 10:30 PM Eastern
Thursday, December 17, 8:30 PM to 10:30 PM Eastern

In this monthly live class, you listen to special audio that helps your body relax deeply while your mind is still wide awake, tapping into expanded consciousness. Then, still on the call, you make something — a timed sprint where you write, play, or create without stopping to judge it. Some meetings, you’ll share one small piece of what you made with the group. Most meetings, you leave with something new that didn’t exist before class started.

👉 Workshops, personal readings, custom natal astrology charts, and more can be found by clicking here. 💫️️️️️️

This post may contain affiliate links, which means The Starfire Codes may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links, at no extra cost to you.

Vous aimez cette publication ?

Achetez un café à Starfire Codes 💫

Plus de Starfire Codes 💫

ConfidentialitéConditions