Trauma and Disability in The X Files, Bl ...

Trauma and Disability in The X Files, Blog 17: Excelsis Dei

Nov 14, 2026
98

In this episode, Mulder and Scully investigate a sexual assault that occurs at a care facility for residents with dementia diseases. A care attendant was assaulted by an invisible assailant who she claims was one of the elderly residents.

This is an episode focused on the disabled elderly and the trauma of sexual assault. Before we deal with those issues, we should acknowledge that this is arguably the worst episode, or at least in the bottom ten, of the series.

There is a clear victim who doesn’t play into the storyline much except to be endangered again, trapped in a flooding shower room with Mulder, near the end of the episode. It is never determined if her assailant is a resident or a ghost. The care facility is not a good facility. So the residents are also victims of neglect and abuse which Mulder and Scully do not investigate. The residents are actually improving. An Asian caregiver is growing mushrooms and administering them to the residents which is having remarkable impact on memory and wellness, but the residents do not want to take them and improve slowly so they steal them and take too much. Because the mushrooms also have a traditional use allowing people to communicate with their ancestors, something has been unleashed-ghosts of residents who have died in the facility. Are they the “villains” in this episode? Only one resident can see them, but when a different resident is overdosing and given medication to counteract the drug’s effect, all the ghosts disappear and the impact of dementia returns to the once improving residents. All of this is compounded by the fact that in this episode Mulder is the skeptic and Scully the believer without any clear indication of why. It’s a mess of an episode.

It seems the general point of the episode is that culturally our society does not honor our elders in the same way that Asian cultures do because we place them in nursing homes where the staff are underpaid. Let’s look at the specific trauma and aging disabled issues.

In terms of trauma, Mulder says that similar rape allegations of invisible assailants are unsubstantiated and, due to trauma, the victims might be suppressing the faces. At one point he tells Scully she concocted it to which Scully points out the stitches from injuries. The victim herself talks about the frustration with being told lack of evidence means no prosecution could be made. Because Mulder is the disbeliever in this case, he comes across as the typical victim blaming male.

On the issues with the aging disabled- except for the Asian caretaker, the other staff are neglectful and verbally abusive. They show no respect or ability to communicate. The administrator is the worst villain to me. She is politically correct telling Mulder that they are not patients but residents. She sings the praises of the care they provide, but she is seldom on the floor to see the neglect or abuse and is dismissive of staff’s concerns. At one point she asks Scully to tell her what is going on in her own facility. She takes no notice of the improvement of the patients and changes none of the rules to accommodate the improvement. She has an employee growing mushrooms in her facility and doesn’t know about it. She doesn’t know how to turn off the water when the shower room is flooding. At the end of the episode the state takes over administration and we briefly glimpse people being treated more respectfully.

The irony is that the one person with the purest motivations, who gave residents a drug to improve their brain health and warned them against taking too much, is remanded into immigration care and detained pending determination of possible deportation. The residents are deprived of the treatment.

In closing, it is worth noting that the episode didn’t glorify or make pretense about the care of the elderly. Without a true villain in the episode, it is possible to see this as a portrayal of systematic failure, where person centered language is more important than respectful care and where the bureaucracy rules never address individual needs. It is unfortunate it wasn’t a better episode so that this message could have been more clearly executed.

Ti piace questo post?

Offri un caffè a Pamela Stafford.

Altro da Pamela Stafford.

PrivacyTerminiRapporto