Why Pet Ownership Is a Moral Choice, not ...

Why Pet Ownership Is a Moral Choice, not a Lifestyle One

Nov 22, 2026
116

I never truly recovered from the loss of my canine friend, so adopting a new one is not simple.

imageGenerated with AI to illustrate the story.

For the past year, my family has been debating what kind of pet to adopt: a cat or a dog. The decision could have been made quickly, but I complicated things with my usual ultra-argumentative approach.

Which breed? Who will be the official caretaker? Who scoops the poop? Who brushes their teeth? Who takes them for walks? About thirty questions in total.

A cat, I noted, costs less to maintain, takes up less space, and is easier to travel with. A dog is more entertaining and can be trained for various “useful” tasks.

I’m also far more inclined to take in a stray than to pay €300–500 for an animal whose only claim to a life of luxury among humans is being born with a pedigree. One: strays are less fortunate. Two: they grow more attached to their owners over time. Three: they have more life experience and are generally smarter.

And if we adopt one (or two), I firmly oppose neutering. It’s not right to deprive them of the chance to have offspring, reducing them to mere personal toys. I’m sure they’d agree if they could speak our language.

So yes, I deliberately made the process difficult. Before you, boys, decide what you want, think about what they would want. Ask yourself: once here, would they feel as good as you do?

And here’s what really matters: draft a list of responsibilities — your responsibilities — and the costs — you will cover — for your new friends. That answer is now twelve months overdue.

Do you think I’m exaggerating? Not at all.

Let me explain why.

My parents had many dogs and cats around their countryside house during the almost 50 years I can remember. None lived inside with us. The dogs were kept on chains, and their menu depended entirely on us until they died. They led boring lives with a minimum guaranteed social package.

The cats came and went freely but often showed up at the door begging for food when hunting rodents and birds failed. From time to time, they brought kittens to feed.

This was an ordinary rural setting during communist times. No one really cared about animal rights in a country where human rights were problematic at best.

Still, there was one great canine love in my life: Cezar (Caesar).

A neighbor gave me a German Shepherd pup when I was fourteen. He was the most beautiful thing I had ever seen. I fell in love with him instantly.

Cezar was smart, playful, non-aggressive, with a great sense of humor and a fluffy muzzle. During winters, I built snow castles, and he would hide inside to scare family members passing by — like a cat.

He was a master of hide-and-seek. Somehow, he understood the game: you wait while everyone hides, then you find them; next time, you hide, and they’ll find you.

He even learned to ignore my false dinner calls meant to trick him. It worked about ten times — then he figured out I was cheating and stopped responding.

Cezar loved to sing when I played the accordion. He had three distinct howling modes, choosing one depending on the music and his mood. And a funny way to show dissatisfaction or lodge a complaint: turning his back to me, lying down, and glancing over his shoulder to make sure I saw his protest.

By his first anniversary, he knew many commands: lie down, wait, stay beside me, stand, come here, go there, walk along, say “hello,” shake hands, jump, crawl. I even taught him a sign language — my own sign language using fingers, palm, and fist. For example, I could stretch out my hand and point with my index finger which way to go. Or I’d bring a finger to my lips — tssss — and he’d stop barking.

He never chewed a single boot. But he became really nervous if anyone tried to steal his food. At least five chickens foolishly lost their lives because of that misunderstanding. My mother was angry, but I punished him lightly — a few slaps on the nose.

The best thing about Cezar was that he would listen to my monologues longer than my father could endure, rotating his head like an owl, as if he understood everything. When he got tired of listening, he’d bark out a few comments and walk away.

As if to say, “Look, I’ve heard enough. Go tell your crap to someone else.”

Unhappy adulthood

Unfortunately, as he grew older, larger, and stronger, we had to lock him in a spacious cage. When he destroyed the cage, we chained him to a wall. That’s when his full and joyful life ended. Soon after, I was admitted to university and moved to the capital. Then my brother enrolled in a technical college and joined me.

My parents — already dealing with thousands of problems at home and work — now had to save money and send food packages to both of us once or twice a month.

Cezar felt neglected. His health decayed. I came home only rarely, as I started working during my second year of studies to support myself in an expensive city.

My friend, meanwhile, stopped barking at stray dogs. He’d never had a real intercourse — he would have welcomed any female (or male) who accidentally visited him. I was young and knew little about pets’ needs. Our communist culture offered scarce information on animal care in open sources.

I was told that he tried to free himself, pulling the chain with all his strength, again and again — until the fur broke open around his neck. Raw flesh.

Elderly people say that dogs do this out of despair, or when they feel they are about to die.

Cezar was 12 when he passed.

My father refused to tell me where he was buried, despite my insistence. I suspect he simply disposed of the body hastily in a remote place.

After Cezar died, I couldn’t bring myself to make a new friend from the animal kingdom. I bought a hamster at a flea market years later but never really had time for it. One day, my neighbor’s cat found it and ate it.

I shared this story to my sons and my wife to defend my stance on pets in the house. To be genuinely happy, a dog must live among dogs and a cat among cats, just like a wolf lives with its pack and a lion with its pride. Find a partner, become parent.

The loss of Cezar was so devastating that my mind refuses to be fooled by dreams of him. Most people sleep unaware. But when Cezar runs toward me, I know immediately it isn’t real. That’s how deep the wound goes.

I will never forgive myself for neglecting my canine friend. And I will not let anyone in my family repeat my mistake.

So, whenever the topic of pet adoption comes up again, I remind them of the core conditions: full commitment, no mutilation. These terms are not negotiable.

For me, pet ownership feels like slavery. But kissing a house pet thousands of times a day while robbing it of free will and the natural instinct to mate is selfishness dressed in affection.

image

Ti piace questo post?

Offri un libro a Aurel Stratan

Altro da Aurel Stratan

PrivacyTermini