Mr. Carney! Spare Us the Performance.

Mr. Carney! Spare Us the Performance.

Nov 12, 2026
483

Your government had months of warning. Canadians deserve to hear that when you start delivering speeches about betrayal.

imageHey, Carney! You stood before the cameras and called the proposed sale of Stellantis's Brampton plant a betrayal. Your government had known for months that a sale was being considered. You might have worked that into the performance. Canadians should not have to chase down the other people involved to find the parts missing from your speech.

On August 12, Stellantis told Unifor it was seriously considering closing and selling Brampton. On September 16, the union wrote to Mélanie Joly asking what role Ottawa had played. By November 4, Unifor was asking for an urgent joint meeting and saying that months of government-company talks had taken place without the union participating. Five days later, the sale agreement was announced.

Your government says it has workers' backs. Their representatives were asking to get into the talks about their own workplace. Having their backs was supposed to mean something better than leaving them outside the room.

CTV then reported, citing three sources, extensive federal involvement in discussions leading to the sale, including more than a dozen meetings over several months. Joly's office denies she negotiated the deal or met Roshel. It also says the government would not approve an arrangement that failed to honour funding commitments or lacked union approval.

Well, I am fresh out of trust. After being burned by Liberal assurances year after year, another denial from a minister's office does not settle a damned thing for me. Your word needs evidence. The letterhead from the PMO has exhausted its usefulness and lost any credibility it once carried.

And there are records. Roshel's lobbyist reported contact with Joly's office on August 21 and September 2. Both entries name Paul Moen, Joly's chief of staff; David McFarlane, Joly's policy director; and Yasmin Atassi, a senior policy adviser. The August meeting also included Rene Sylvestre, an investment adviser in Joly's minister's office. The September meeting included Brian Botting, Joly's director of defence industrial strategy.

So… Joly's chief of staff. Joly's policy director. Joly's advisers. Her own team was dealing with Roshel. The records give broad subjects, not a transcript of the conversations, but spare me the idea that saying she personally did not meet them settles the matter.

Picture this: your chief of staff, policy director and advisers have contact with the company considering buying a plant at the centre of a major dispute in your own department. Somehow, nobody thinks to mention anything useful to you? What are we supposed to imagine they discussed? The weather in Brampton and a reasonably priced lunch?

Given what was at stake, I find it incredibly hard to believe Joly was not briefed. If she was, she owes Canadians an account of what she knew. If her own senior staff left her in the dark, that is a different failure, but still with her name on the door.

Joly had already told Parliament in October 2025 that Ottawa would use the full force of the law if Stellantis did not bring production back to Brampton. More than a year later, we get a signed sale agreement and another helping of meaningless tough talking word salads . The threat has had plenty of airtime. The result is proving much, much harder to locate.

Then there was the funding contract. MPs asked to see it. They received a copy with the relevant parts blacked out. Officials initially pointed to Stellantis over the redactions. Stellantis said the government proposed them. The deputy minister later corrected his account and acknowledged that government officials had initially made them. This was the same session we learned Melanie Joly didn't read the contract she signed. The committee eventually got the full contract. All that trouble to examine the agreement, while Canadians were being told how firmly the government had things in hand. Utter bullspit!

That is what I find insulting, Mr. Carney. We hear the promise, the threat and the outrage. Then union letters, committee testimony and reporting fill in what your presentation left out. Canadians should not need a detective's licence to follow their own government. We already have jobs. I can think of a few hundred people in Brampton that would very much like theirs back.

Whatever Donald Trump's tariffs contributed to this mess, they do not explain your government's conduct. They do not explain why workers' representatives were asking to join the talks. They do not turn months of warning into a surprise. Trump may be useful at your microphone, but he does not get assigned responsibility for what your own government knew and did.

You sold yourself as the man equipped to manage a crisis. Condemning an outcome does not establish that you managed it well. Neither does holding months of meetings before announcing that the result is unacceptable. It establishes that you either attended meetings or were briefed on the discussions.

So spare those workers the wounded expression. Your government had warning. Your minister made promises. The union raised the alarm. You cannot now stand before Canadians as though your administration's contribution is to be disappointed alongside them.

You called it a betrayal, Mr. Carney. Open the door. Your government belongs in the growing line of people and things that betray Canadians.

You should be mortified and ashamed at being caught lying yet again.

Melanie in Saskatchewan

If you haven't already, please consider signing my House of Commons petition e-7823 demanding full disclosure, retained sovereignty and a national referendum before Carney joins Canada to a foreign parliamentary EU body that no one voted for and for which Carney has no mandate. If you have signed already, I gratefully thank you and ask that you share the petition to a friend. Every Canadian regardless of political stripe should have a say on this critical, nation-altering proposal.

✍️🏻 https://www.ourcommons.ca/petitions/en/Petition/Sign/e-7823

Подобається цей допис?

Купити для Melanie in Saskatchewan каву

Більше від Melanie in Saskatchewan