Explain How This Makes Us Sovereign. Slo ...

Explain How This Makes Us Sovereign. Slowly.

Nov 10, 2026
286

Ottawa is making Canada more financially entangled with Beijing. Spare me the sales pitch. Show me how this ends.

imageI'm supposed to believe that making Canada more financially entangled with Beijing strengthens our sovereignty. So, walk me through that Liberals. Start at the beginning. Include the plot parts you normally leave out of the announcement, and tell the full story.

On November 8 and 9, Francois-Philippe Champagne and Maninder Sidhu co-chaired economic and financial talks with Chinese Vice-Premier He Lifeng in Vancouver. Officials signed agreements covering finance-ministry cooperation, financial regulatory dialogue and a financial working group. Their joint statement includes cooperation on financial-services market access.

That's quite the relationship to deepen while telling Canadians we need more control over our own future by being Masters of our destiny. Especially with this "I just got here" Liberal government.

Our House of Commons voted 266–0 in 2021 to recognize genocide against Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims. Our intelligence service identifies Beijing among the principal perpetrators of espionage and foreign interference against Canada. Sustained and persistent interference and espionage are an everyday occurrence and do I really have to pull The Two Michaels card here?

Apparently the investment presentation comes separately from the security briefing the Liberals demand Pierre undergo in their epic "security clearance" hissy fits. I'm repulsed by the casualness of it all, and so should you be. Canadians are expected to absorb the warnings about stolen information and foreign interference, then applaud when ministers announce another layer of cooperation.

What changed? The risks? The protections? Did polling shift? Or is it just the enthusiasm of the Liberal connected stakeholders? Show us what connects to what, because the financial agenda established earlier this year includes regulation, anti-money laundering and cross-border capital flows.

Once upon a time I worked a stint at NAPA. I understand that systems have to communicate, particularlyinternational systems. Part numbers, barcodes, orders. Information has to correspond across a border for a transaction to work. Banking has its own connections: payment instructions, identification, compliance checks. So explain which connections these arrangements require. Which institutions exchange information? What information? Where is it stored? Who can obtain it? How can I opt out?

I'm not claiming this announcement gives Beijing access to everyone's bank account. I'm asking for the architecture and the restrictions before another politician assures me there's nothing to worry about. We've had rather enough reassurances, thanks.

Then there's the steel.

On November 4, Minister Sidhu announced favourable Chinese market access for Canadian canola meal, peas, lobster and crab would continue through 2028. Canada will also extend tariff relief for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products Ottawa says are not made here. The existing relief schedule includes unfinished steel tubes suitable for manufacturing seamless line pipe, aka pipelines, and inputs for further manufacturing, alongside other products. The precise coverage of the announced extension still needs checking against its implementing rules.

However... suppose we need those imports. Where is the corresponding plan to make those same strategically important inputs here, you know, by being our own best customer in order to build Canada strong and protect our sovereignty? That is my point. Carney sells Canadian strength and sovereignty at every microphone shoved under his nose. So then show me, show all Canadians, the facilities, the investment and the production dates that make us less dependent on ANY other nation! "We don't make it here" cannot become the excuse next year, and the year after that. By then we'll have a minister announcing a task force to investigate why we don't make it here.

Think about it for a beat... other countries use pipelines too. So, using Carney's own logic about building Canada strong by being our own best customer, Ottawa needs to assess the global demand for these parts that Ottawa says we don't make here. Price out Canadian production and show us all how investing in our own facilities could supply Canadian industries instead and give us something to sell abroad. I mean, isn't that the sovereignty pitch? Make it here. Buy it here. Compete out there. You know, because… Trump. 🤦🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️

Instead, we're supposed to depend on a different country and congratulate Carney for making us independent. Because when the next dispute arrives, our farmers still need customers and our manufacturers still need supplies. An agreement linking agricultural access with industrial concessions does not make that exposure vanish. What have we built that lets us refuse the next demand? And please don't say it's about another relationship. Please... get as serious as you profess to be!

The European Commission itself identifies concerns about China's cybersecurity rules, intellectual-property enforcement and pressures leading to technology transfer. Its approach includes reducing critical dependencies. So how is this all supposed to work Mark?

Put that beside Canada's announcements and for once, just clearly and concisely explain which dependencies we're reducing, which are we creating, and which are we just trading off temporarily.

Bear with me... I have a theory about the politics underneath this.

I suspect Carney is counting on our abject exhaustion. People trying to keep a business alive don't have unlimited time to examine international agreements. Families struggling through another month don't have unlimited patience for promises either. Offer relief and scrutiny starts sounding like an obstacle.

My theory is that this government is deliberately allowing economic pain to drag on until Canadians become so dependent on Liberal government relief payments and benefit programs that we're afraid to question whatever comes next. We pay into the system, struggle to afford our own lives, then wait for the government to announce how much help we'll get buying groceries, feeding our children or seeing a dentist. Gee, like that's some kind of independence.

That's the dependence I'm talking about: needing the next payment to make it through the month. Once survival takes priority over scrutiny, Ottawa can sell us unpalatable agreements and partnerships as our salvation. The questions we should be asking get shoved aside because people need relief now. When hungry enough, exhausted enough, or frightened enough of losing what little relief you have, “What are we giving up?” becomes “How soon does it start?”

That is what my gut tells me Carney is counting on. But I am done accepting a government's description of its intentions as evidence of its results. Show us the whole arrangement:

☆ What does Canada REALLY gain?
☆ What does Canada REALLY concede?
☆ What information moves, and in which direction?
☆ What Canadian GDP capacity gets built?
☆ What remains prohibited?
☆ How does this fit our North American trade relationship?

And... exactly HOW do we walk away if we need to? A sovereignty plan that works only while Beijing is agreeable leaves Beijing deciding how sovereign we get to be. And the last time I checked, nobody voted for this. I know I didn't.

Sincerely done with it all,
Melanie in Saskatchewan


While I have you here...

Your country is not Carney's to sign away while you're busy trying to afford supper: sign e-7823 and demand the full Canada–EU terms and a referendum ✍️🏻👇🏻

https://www.ourcommons.ca/petitions/en/Petition/Sign/e-7823 Article

Vous aimez cette publication ?

Achetez un café à Melanie in Saskatchewan

Plus de Melanie in Saskatchewan