The Campaign to Make the Press Blame Meg ...

The Campaign to Make the Press Blame Meghan

Nov 18, 2026
422

imageThere have been deeply troubling reports that journalists and bloggers are receiving emails urging them to blame Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, for her estranged father's alleged crimes.

The emails described by Celebitchy and Feminegra reportedly make much the same case: Meghan knew about allegations concerning her father, so she should have done more, said more or somehow taken responsibility for what happened next. Some invoke Florida law to suggest her failure to act publicly makes her culpable. We don't know whether the messages came from one person or several, but their similarity demands scrutiny.

The Telegraph's Camilla Tominey also received an email making a similar argument. She and royal editor Hannah Furness were contacted by someone identifying themselves as a survivor of child sexual abuse, questioning why the Sussexes had not pursued the allegations against Thomas Markle more aggressively.

Tominey described it as:

“A profoundly uncomfortable question, but an important one.”

The argument was repeated on the Telegraph's podcast:

“Why did she never follow up with police after first hearing about the claims eight years ago?”

There are legitimate questions about what Meghan was told and how the authorities handled the information. But notice the shift. The central institutional question - why did the police fail to pass the information to other law-enforcement agencies? - becomes a question about why Meghan didn't personally pursue the matter for years.

Tominey says a survivor contacted her. We don’t know that this correspondent was behind the emails sent to other publications, or that the approaches were coordinated. But the similarity is striking. Who contacted the Telegraph? Was their account independently verified? Did the paper know other outlets had received similar approaches? Did it investigate who was promoting this argument, and why?

There are, sadly, any number of possibilities as to who could be behind this campaign. Her half-sister Samantha Markle’s Twitter account was suspended after harassing Meghan for years. Kensington Palace staff have been revealed to have been briefing against Harry and Meghan. And then there are the columnists whose hostility has been very public: Jeremy Clarkson famously declared that he hated Meghan “on a cellular level”.

This history illustrates why journalists should be particularly alert to attempts to manipulate coverage of Meghan, and why identifying the source, the motive and any connections between those approaching newsrooms matters.

A source's claim doesn't become independent evidence simply because it appears in a newspaper. Nor does an argument become more credible through repetition.

There is history here, too. The media's relationship with Thomas Markle was not simply that of passive observers: the publication of extracts from Meghan's private letter to her father, and a senior Mail on Sunday journalist's involvement, formed part of Meghan's successful privacy and copyright case against Associated Newspapers. Some outlets helped turn this family estrangement into a public spectacle.

There’s also a crucial distinction between Meghan knowing allegations had been made and knowing the police had failed to act. The Metropolitan Police confirmed it received a letter in January 2019 containing allegations about conduct outside the UK. It passed the information to the shared office of the Prince and Princess of Wales and the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, but did not pass it to other law-enforcement agencies at the time. Its handling is now under scrutiny.

Meghan says she was assured the allegations were being investigated and trusted the authorities to protect other families. If someone is told the police are dealing with a matter, it’s hardly self-evident that they should launch their own investigation or publicise allegations about a family member. Yet the media discussion keeps returning to what Meghan should have done, rather than what the authorities did - or failed to do. Precisely the shift of blame the emails appear to encourage.

Which leads us to the question: where are the other newsrooms?

Have the Daily Mail, The Sun, The Mirror, The Express, GB News or other royal commentators received similar emails? Have journalists been given the same claims or suggested lines of attack? Have editors compared notes? Has anyone tried to establish whether the approaches are connected? And if they have received them, will they tell their readers?

Journalists receive tips every day. That's normal, and often valuable. But a tip is a starting point for investigation, not an instruction to adopt the source's interpretation. A journalist must establish what a source knows, how they know it, whether the claims can be verified and why the source is bringing them forward. What do they stand to gain? Do they have a personal grievance or an interest in a particular outcome? Are they acting alone, or trying to persuade several publications to promote the same narrative?

None of this automatically discredits a source. It is basic journalism. But when similar approaches reach multiple newsrooms, the responsibility to investigate becomes even greater. Editors should be comparing the messages, checking whether the senders are connected and examining whose interests are being served. They shouldn’t simply publish the material and leave readers to assume it has been independently tested.

The danger is argument laundering: a claim begins in an email, appears in a column, is repeated on a podcast and then cited elsewhere as evidence that “questions are being asked”. Repetition creates the appearance of independent momentum, even when everyone may be drawing on the same source or assumptions. But repetition is not corroboration, and a question can imply responsibility without ever making an explicit accusation.

There are enough reported approaches, and enough similarity in the arguments, for responsible news organisations to investigate whether there is a campaign. They shouldn't wait for someone else to prove it. Finding out is their job.

This isn't simply a matter of good practice; it goes to the heart of journalistic ethics. The National Union of Journalists' Code of Conduct specifically requires journalists to 

“resist threats or any other inducements to influence, distort or suppress information”. 

The IPSO Editors' Code also places responsibility on editors to uphold accuracy and distinguish fact from conjecture. These principles exist for precisely this reason: journalists must exercise independent judgement, not allow themselves to be used to advance somebody else's interests. That means scrutinising not only the information they receive, but the motives and methods of those seeking to influence their coverage.

If the approaches are unrelated, that should be discoverable. If they’re connected, the public has a right to know. And if newsrooms haven't bothered to investigate their origins, motives or possible connections, that is a failure of journalism.

The question isn't simply who is trying to tell journalists what to write. It's whether journalists are doing their job - or allowing themselves to become the instruments of someone else's agenda.

Подобається цей допис?

Купити для JP Caonabo каву

1 коментар

Більше від JP Caonabo

КонфіденційністьУмови