Children Are Not a Captive Audience

Children Are Not a Captive Audience

Nov 03, 2026
397

On Fred Rogers, Raffi, Ms. Rachel, political misinformation, and the responsibility adults keep handing back to children.

I've been thinking about Fred Rogers lately.

Specifically, I've been thinking about how much money he could have made.

He had one of the most recognizable children's television programs in American history. Generations of children trusted him. Parents trusted him. And he understood something about that relationship that I wish more adults working in children's media understood today.

Trust is not an invitation to sell someone something.

Fred Rogers was famously uncomfortable with commercializing his relationship with children. He resisted turning Mister Rogers' Neighborhood into a merchandising machine, even as children's television became increasingly entangled with toy companies and advertising.

And I find that remarkable.

Because we've built an economy where nearly every relationship, every interest, every moment of attention can become an opportunity to sell something.

Including childhood.

Of course, I'm not opposed to children having toys. I have purchased plenty of toys over the years. Some were educational. Some were genuinely fun. Some were expensive pieces of plastic that entertained my children for approximately eleven minutes when they rather played with the box.

That's not really what I'm talking about.

I'm talking about the difference between creating something for children and creating something to profit from their developing ability to understand the world.

And lately, I've been thinking about that distinction in the context of political misinformation.

Children don't have to follow politics to encounter political messaging.

I have two children, and I've spent more than fifteen years working in education.

I've watched children grow up with technology that adults are still trying to understand.

A child can open YouTube to watch someone play Minecraft and, a few videos later, encounter commentary about immigration, transgender people, public schools, or elections.

Sometimes the content is an advertisement. Sometimes it's an influencer sharing an opinion. Sometimes it's a "joke" that's rooted in a stereotype. Sometimes it's presented as a factual claim with absolutely no evidence attached.

And sometimes it's a mixture of all four.

I think about the child who hears a creator confidently explain that public schools are secretly doing something terrible.

The creator has hundreds of thousands of followers. The comments are full of agreement. The video has been shared thousands of times.

To a child, that can look an awful lot like credibility.

And that's where I become concerned.

Because popularity is not evidence, confidence is certainly not expertise, and repetition does not make something true. Yet children are increasingly expected to navigate information environments designed by adults, funded by adults, and optimized to hold their attention. Then, when something goes wrong, we tell children they need better media literacy.

I agree that they need media literacy. I also think that's a remarkably convenient place for adults to end the conversation.

Raffi understood that children deserve something different.

I grew up with Raffi.

Baby Beluga remains one of those songs that can transport me back to childhood almost immediately. But what interests me most about Raffi today isn't his music. It's his philosophy. Raffi has spent decades advocating for what he calls Child Honouring, a framework grounded in respecting children's developmental needs, dignity, and rights.

He has also spoken publicly about refusing lucrative commercial opportunities because he didn't want to use children's affection for his music to sell them products. I wish I could remember the NPR show I first heard this on over a decade ago. I still consider what that requires.

A person creates something children love. Companies recognize the financial opportunity. And that person decides there are limits to what they'll do with the relationship they've built. The children matter more than money. I keep returning to that.

Children are still developing their understanding of persuasion. Young children can struggle to recognize advertising as advertising. Older children and teenagers become more sophisticated, but recognizing that someone is trying to influence them doesn't automatically make them immune.

Adults understand this well enough when we're discussing tobacco advertising, age-inappropriate products, or online privacy. But political messaging seems to occupy a strange exception in our collective imagination. We can recognize that children are impressionable when someone is selling them a toy. Yet we seem far less prepared to discuss what happens when someone is selling them fear. The fear of immigrants, people whose identities are different from their own, fear of books, or that another group of people is somehow responsible for everything going wrong in their community.

Those messages have consequences, even when they don't arrive as a traditional campaign advertisement.

And then there's Ms. Rachel.

I think Ms. Rachel is a particularly interesting contemporary example because she's navigating a media environment that Fred Rogers and Raffi never had to navigate in quite the same way. Her children's programming is grounded in early childhood development, language acquisition, repetition, music, and connection.

But she's also become a public advocate for children experiencing war, hunger, displacement, and humanitarian crises. And I appreciate the distinction she makes between those roles. Her educational videos are designed for young children. Her advocacy is largely directed toward adults.

She's used her public platform to speak about children in Gaza and elsewhere, including children whose experiences and circumstances are very different from those of her primary audience. There's a difference between using children's programming to tell children what political positions to adopt and using an adult-facing platform to advocate for children's well-being.

There's also a difference between keeping content developmentally appropriate and pretending that the conditions affecting children's lives are somehow outside an educator's concern. Children don't stop being children because they were born on the other side of a border. Their need for food, safety, education, and human connection doesn't change with their nationality or citizenship. I don't need every children's entertainer to become a political commentator.

But I do think educators have a responsibility to consider how their work relates to the lives and rights of children. And I think adults should be capable of discussing that responsibility without turning every disagreement into a culture war.

What happened to the idea of public-interest media?

This is also why I keep thinking about PBS and NPR. They aren't identical institutions, and neither is free from criticism. But they represent an important idea: media can exist to serve a public purpose rather than simply maximize advertising revenue. Public broadcasting has long operated under different rules from commercial television, including restrictions on paid political advertising. PBS children's programming has historically emphasized educational value and developmental appropriateness.

There are still sponsors. There are still funding pressures. There are still editorial decisions worth examining. But the underlying model asks a different question. What does the public need from this programming? That's a different question from asking what will generate the most clicks, the longest viewing session, or the highest advertising revenue. And I think we need to be much more curious about what those different incentives produce.

If a platform earns money by keeping people watching, it has a financial interest in capturing attention. If a political campaign earns support by generating fear or outrage, it may have an incentive to create messages that provoke those emotions. And when those incentives intersect with children's developing understanding of the world, I think adults have some difficult questions to answer.

Why do we expect children to do all the work?

One of the things I teach children is how to investigate information. I want my children to know the difference between a fact, an opinion, and a prediction. I want them to understand that a photograph can be real while its caption is misleading. I want them to recognize that someone can tell a technically accurate story while leaving out information that changes its meaning. I want them to ask where a claim originated, whether the evidence supports it, and what might change their minds. And I especially want them to practice those skills when the information confirms something they already believe.

That's the harder work.

But I also think we've made a mistake in treating media literacy as though it were primarily a matter of individual responsibility. Imagine building a playground with dangerous equipment and then congratulating ourselves for teaching children how to avoid getting hurt. We might teach them to recognize the hazards. We would also expect the adults responsible for the playground to make it safer.

Why should digital environments be different? YouTube restricts political advertising in content designated for children and on supervised accounts for younger users. Google also limits personalized advertising to minors. But paid advertisements are only one way political messaging reaches children.

A creator can introduce political commentary into entertainment. An influencer can make an unsupported claim. A misleading video can circulate without being purchased as an election ad. And older children may use the broader platform rather than a supervised experience. So the question cannot begin and end with whether a particular advertisement violates a platform's policy.

We need to examine the environment itself.

I think we need a much more serious conversation about political advertising.

In the United States, political speech receives significant constitutional protection. A government that can decide which political opinions are permissible has enormous power to suppress dissent. That's a legitimate concern, particularly when we consider the history of governments targeting civil rights organizers, antiwar movements, and people challenging established power.

But protecting political expression and protecting deliberate deception are not exactly the same conversation. We already distinguish commercial advertising from political speech in important areas of law. And political campaigns are subject to certain disclosure requirements, even though there is no universal federal requirement that every factual claim in a political advertisement be independently verified.

  • What would legislation restricting paid political advertising directed at minors look like?

  • Could platforms be required to provide more transparency about who funds political messages and how those messages are distributed?

  • What would meaningful accountability for demonstrably false factual claims require? Who would determine whether a claim was false?

  • How would an independent review process protect dissent, satire, journalism, and legitimate political disagreement?

Those last questions matter as much as the first ones.

I don't want a government agency deciding which political beliefs children are allowed to encounter. I do want us to consider whether the current system adequately protects against exploitation and deception. Those are different goals, and any serious proposal would need to address both.

Children deserve access to politics. They also deserve protection from exploitation.

I don't believe children are too young to learn about politics. Quite the opposite. Children can learn about fairness, public resources, laws, voting, representation, and the responsibilities people have to one another. They can investigate why some neighborhoods have well-funded libraries while others don't. They can learn how a school board makes decisions. They can study the history of voting rights and ask why those rights have expanded for some groups while being restricted for others. They can learn how people organize to change laws. And they can disagree.

I want my children to develop political understanding. I just don't want that understanding shaped primarily by whoever is most successful at capturing their attention. There's a difference between helping children investigate the world and attempting to recruit them into an adult's political worldview before they've developed the tools to evaluate it.

There's also a difference between introducing children to the existence of people who are different from them and using dehumanizing messages to teach children to fear those people. Children can learn that transgender people exist. They can learn that families have different structures. They can learn about immigration, religion, poverty, and political disagreement. None of those subjects requires teaching children that a group of people is inherently dangerous or less deserving of dignity. And children deserve opportunities to ask questions about complicated issues without being handed an enemy.

The part I keep coming back to

I spend a lot of time thinking about what children need to learn.

That's part of being a mother. It's part of being an educator.

But lately, I'm equally interested in what adults need to stop doing.

I want my children to become critical thinkers.

I want them to recognize persuasion.

I want them to question confident people, including the adults they admire.

I want them to understand that an algorithm isn't a teacher and that a popular opinion isn't necessarily a well-supported one.

And I want them to know that sometimes the most intellectually responsible thing they can say is, "I don't know enough to decide yet."

But I don't want the responsibility for protecting children from manipulation to rest entirely on children.

Adults write the laws.

Adults design the platforms.

Adults purchase the advertisements.

Adults establish the incentives.

Adults decide which protections are worth enforcing.

Fred Rogers understood that his relationship with children came with responsibilities.

Raffi understood that children's trust shouldn't automatically become a commercial opportunity.

Ms. Rachel offers a contemporary example of an educator distinguishing between what young children need from educational programming and what adults need to hear about children's lives.

None of these examples provides a complete answer to the challenges of today's media environment.

But they give us something worth considering.

What would change if the adults creating media for children began with the question, "What do children need?" rather than "What can we get them to watch?"

And what would change if policymakers approached children's digital environments with the same seriousness we bring to their physical safety?

I think those are questions worth asking.

Because teaching children to recognize manipulation doesn't excuse the adults who create, distribute, or profit from it.

And children deserve better than being handed the responsibility for solving problems adults created.


A question for the community

I've been thinking about the media that shaped my own childhood, and the media shaping my children's understanding of the world today.

I'd love to know: What boundaries should exist around advertising and political messaging directed at children? And where should we draw the line between protecting children and ensuring they have access to information about the world?

I read the comments, and I especially appreciate thoughtful disagreement.

If this essay was useful, becoming a member on Buy Me a Coffee helps me continue researching, writing, and creating educational resources for families and educators.

Happy Election Day,

I'm rooting for you,

Britt

Further reading

Enjoy this post?

Buy Britt Hawthorne a coffee

1 comment

More from Britt Hawthorne