The Louder the Defense

The Louder the Defense

Oct 31, 2026
13

—— A follow-up to “Death Rattle: Business Schools Defend Themselves”

Since my last post, the defense has grown. Seven professors, among them Nicolai Foss of Copenhagen Business School, have co-signed a reply to Christopher Marquis. It is the most careful defense so far, but it adds a new move: it recasts an institutional critique as an ideological one. Marquis becomes a “progressive” who treats profit as evil, and the question of what business schools actually optimize for becomes a question of left versus right. For the first time, the defense looks outward, but to half an audience rather than the whole. That alone is telling: business schools can no longer count on a consensus across the aisle.

It helps to compare. When universities cut philosophy and sociology departments, the defenses were real but barely heard. There was no audience, and little money at stake. Mathematics, facing AI, has been strikingly candid. Its leading figures, such as Terence Tao, openly admit the field has a problem it needs to think through. They can afford to. A proof is right or wrong regardless of who is paying.

Business schools sit at the other extreme. Their legitimacy rests almost entirely on the outside: on applicants, employers, and rankings. So when that external verdict wavers, they can neither decline quietly nor speak candidly. They have to shout.

The pattern seems simple. The more a field’s legitimacy depends on outside approval, the louder it defends itself in a crisis. Fear, not strength, is what raises the voice. The more it rests on internal standards, the more freely it can admit what is wrong. Candor, it turns out, is a luxury of the secure.

image

Enjoy this post?

Buy Kerwin Meeeooow a cocktail

More from Kerwin Meeeooow

PrivacyTerms